Best Off-line programming software

  • AD
  • Depends on the process, and the skills of the people using the sim software. Each brand has its own learning curve. And each software is going to have its own strengths and weaknesses.


    There's also an issue of fidelity. One of the reasons PS is so expensive is that you can (for an extra fee) buy a module for each make&model of robot that guarantees a valid virtual emulation of the real robot's physical performance -- path, speed, accel, etc. For projects that require accurate simulation cycle time estimates before starting to build anything, that can be important.


    Of course, each robot brand offers their own brand-specific simulation software, in varying degrees of usability, but are generally motion-accurate to their own robots.


    Specific processes may require different simulation software, or at least different add-on modules. Using Delmia for paint, for example, requires a different toolset than using Delmia for drilling operations. And applications where someone wants to use a robot as if it were a CNC machine often require very specific software sets.

  • Really, the entire Simulation side of the industry is ripe for some enterprising startup to make a really disruptive entry, with a lower-cost alternative that doesn't have all the legacy baggage of the Big Dogs.


    We are trying man, I can tell you we are trying really hard days in and days out.
    But it's hard.
    Keeping the cost down comes with limitations.
    We can't afford to have a huge team of dev to create all the features we are dreaming of.
    We can't afford to have ppl with good experience with each robot brand as there are so many out there.


    Every penny we make we reinvest in development. No fancy office, almost no overhead. Just a small group of ppl passionate about robotics trying to bring a cost-effective alternative to the field.

    Anyway, going back to work. ^^


    And yes Collin is one of our resellers, a nice and friendly one. But I had to check the name after reading his post because it looked really really shady at first.
    I'm super happy to see that you guys are keeping an eye open for that. We really appreciate it. :love:

    RoboDK - Simulation and Offline programming software for industrial and collaborative robots.

    Visit us at RoboDK.com
    Take a look at our tutorial videos on our YouTube channel.

  • in our situation we are actually only looking at a simulation software that can generate a robot program where we can add IO inline or edit the postprocessor based on what we needed just like for welding on/off, bending, 3d printers or material handling with gripper on/off and wait sgnals. just for making things easier rather than doing it the old ways of manual programming.

  • Right now I am in the middle between RoboDK and Robotmaster for our Kuka KR-120 2700 KRC4 Extra HA for Milling stone. It is a very difficult choice. The RoboDK seem like a very passionate group of programmers that provide VERY in depth reading material and Videos from Jeremy. Robotmaster is almost completely locked down in terms of trial (though a reseller has offered us a 30 day monitored experience). Robotmaster is VERY expensive and has on-site training, but I like the fact I can go home and watch Jer's tutorials, which are amazing by the way. I get a VERY corporate feeling from the Robotmaster sales people. Not really a good one, but the features seem impressive.


    Jeremy,


    Change my mind. I need multi axis milling using a 7th axis table for milling sculptures and 3 axis for lettering. I have all of the tooling, just need the OLS program.


    I am using Mastercam 2022 Mill with the Multi-Axis add on package. We are leasing it for now.


    Mike Rhodes

  • I'm not Jeremy, but you should probably tag or PM him, so he gets an alert about this. I know he's generally pretty busy.

    Thanks, SkyeFire! Busy I am, fortunately! ^^


    Hi Mike!

    Thanks for the great comment! Our team and I work hard on the content we release!


    I answered your PM, BTW.


    Ok, about the "Change my mind." Let's give it a go.


    Let's get this out the way first.

    I don't have any experience with Robotmaster.
    I know some of their capabilities and features through research and demo, but nothing more than that.


    We are indeed just a group of "industrial robot ppl" who had a problem "Simulating and generating robot programs for multiple brands without having to sell a kidney along the way."
    So we made one...

    ("Made"... "Make" would make more sense as it's a never-ending process/project. One that we are pretty passionate about, to be honest.)
    We created a tool to help you bridge the gap between your idea and a working robot by removing some of the programming pain points.
    But it's still just a tool; it won't do everything for you. It's so flexible that we can cover a lot of use cases, but the user still needs to find the correct parameters for his project.


    We do Stone Milling with other customers, using external axes.
    Have you tried our software?

    Inside RoboDK, you can recreate your station by importing the robot from our library, creating your external axes, etc. (explained with the videos you already know about).

    You can then Sync the robot and the external axis together.

    All of this should be pretty straightforward.

    You mentioned using Mastercam.
    RoboDK has a plugin for MasterCAM that lets you transfer your CAM program directly to RoboDK with just the click of a button.
    So that's one step you won't have to bother about later.

    Where things will get a bit more complicated is when you will have to optimize the path with the external axis.
    It might go well for the first few parts, and you might find the right set of parameters in a few minutes, or you might spend a reasonable amount of time figuring out the right recipe for your setup.
    Once you know about your system, generating new parts is very fast.

    We do not offer on-site support/training, but we provide a call with the purchase of a license.
    You can then purchase paid support bundle if you need our direct help. Otherwise, we provide support via email. (Exactly what I was doing before ending up here.)


    I don't know what to say; try it out; if it's a tool for you, great.
    It's the kind of tool that you might need to think around a bit to use the full potential of, but if you can do so, it's super powerful.
    (Talking as Jeremy, not Jeremy from RoboDK. I work at RoboDK because I love the product, not the other way around. You can do so much with that thing for the price.)



    Anyway, I hope it helps.
    Robotmaster must be a good product; they've been out there for years, and a bunch of people are using it.
    It won't be a wrong choice if you go down that road.
    Have a great day.


    Jeremy

    RoboDK - Simulation and Offline programming software for industrial and collaborative robots.

    Visit us at RoboDK.com
    Take a look at our tutorial videos on our YouTube channel.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new account
Sign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign in Now